Philosophy of Interaction what it makes of a person, and what it ought to
A research axis by Meng-Han Lee (Zaious)
“AI philosophy mostly asks about the machine: what it is, what it can do, what it ought to do.
This axis asks what a designed interaction makes of the person on the other side of it.”
The Question
Interaction is the word that names the field of human–computer interaction, yet the field has never settled what interaction, at bottom, does to the person who lives through it. It asks what an interface affords, how it mediates, whether it is usable and trusted. This axis asks the question those leave out: how designed interaction constitutes the human — how sustained life inside a designed, responsive, asymmetric environment forms, in part, a person’s agency, self-understanding, capacities and responsibility.
That technology constitutes people is not a new thought. This axis’s nearest neighbour is the philosophy of technology, which takes the relation between people and technology as its unit and does not hold the person fixed; in Peter-Paul Verbeek’s mediation theory, one of its most developed forms alongside Don Ihde’s, mediation is the mutual constitution of subject and object. What sets the axis apart are three qualifiers — the interaction is designed, it responds, and it is asymmetric — and its focus on answerability.
Within HCI, the unit of analysis moves from how an interaction is construed or mediated to what it makes of the person. The research calls this constitutive-of-being interaction.
Why It Matters Now
Under human-in-the-loop arrangements, responsibility is assigned to the person: the system acts, the human answers for it. A prior question is seldom asked where it arises — is that person still able to answer, or is the capacity responsibility presumes being worn down by the interaction itself?
That gives responsible design a question it has had no name for: is the formation reversible — can the person come to see it, take it back, undo it? Reversibility is treated here as a neutral measuring dimension, not a goal: it weighs the need to be able to go back as well as the irreversibility a person chooses. The neutrality belongs to the measure. The normative weight falls on whether the person knows what is being formed in them, and chooses it.
The Position
Constitute without dissolving. Designed interaction will shape people; the question is whether a person remains who can recognise themselves and take themselves back. If responsibility means that someone can be asked, can commit, and can withdraw, then a continuous subject — one that can be formed without being dissolved — is its practical precondition.
Two working criteria sit alongside this position. A cognitive environment should scaffold the way a person already thinks, rather than quietly substitute a designed one. And in education, a given use of AI should still leave the learner a seam they ought to cross themselves — the education line has its own page.
Asked From the Craft Floor
The question is asked by someone who designs, deploys and lives inside these systems, without formal training in philosophy. That position lets the question be seen: being on the craft floor makes it urgent to know which questions to put, and which theory could answer them. It can also skew it. The designer, the operator and the theorist are one person, and the people being formed appear in this work only through other researchers’ studies and reports, not yet in data of its own — which is why the research is looking for empirical collaborators.
AI philosophy’s main questions — mind, value and alignment, responsibility and moral status — mostly take the machine as their unit. This axis takes the person: what designed interaction makes of them.
Published Work so far
How Designed Interaction Constitutes the Human: A Perspective AI Philosophy Has Yet to Reach — Who Is Asking on the Craft Floor?
被設計的互動如何構成人:AI 哲學未及的視角,技藝現場誰在提問?
- Status
- Presented · Taiwan Philosophical Association 2026 Conference, “AI Philosophy in Taiwan” panel · 2026-11-15 · in Traditional Chinese
Toward a Philosophy of Interaction: How Designed Interaction Constitutes the Human, and Why Its Reversibility Now Matters
- Status
- Preprint · Zenodo · 2026-07-07
Idiosyncratic Cognitive Amplification: A Framework for Designing Cognitive Environments That Scaffold Rather Than Substitute
- Status
- Preprint · Zenodo · 2026-05-29
Statuses are stated as-is; preprints are public and citable but not journal publications. This page describes a research direction — the positioning paper leaves the mechanism of constitution, and a full criterion for a person’s continuity, as open questions.
Where This Sits in the Programme
The first of three axes around one question — how does designed interaction constitute the human? This axis asks what it makes of a person, and how it ought to. The sociological axis asks how humans and agents form social structure together (ASAF); the psychological axis asks who is formed, and stays the same person. See the full programme ↗